How to handle Windows Security pop up in IE [Windows 10] using Selenium

So I'm using Selenium Webdriver. On my machine running Windows 7, I can handle the Windows Security pop up using

driver.switchTo().alert().authenticateUsing(new UserAndPassword([Credentials]));

But in Windows 10, I cannot. The program doesn't recognize it as an alert and just pauses until it terminates. I've tried researching similar issues but have had no luck. This is still working in IE as well, not in Edge.